Talk:Ultimate
From CarlWiki
Is there any reason to maintain both the "Ultimate" and the "Frisbee" pages?
- You could do it either way, really, but you're right that right now they overlap a great deal. I think a frisbee article focusing mainly on the frisbee culture at Carleton would be best, while the ultimate article should be on it as a more formal sport. --Trevor Burnham '07 00:22, 18 Sep 2005 (PDT)
That's a good distinction and a good reason to maintain separate pages.
I think the pages should be merged since both the frisbee and ultimate articles discuss the team sport Ultimate. If you want an article on frisbee culture, then it should discuss things like the frisbee golf course and the frisbee toss during NSW, and it should not be in Category: Club sports. Sarah Vigeland '06 18:39, 26 April 2006 (PDT)